Cartoon by Reza Aghili

Iranians fear warnings that their ties with Taliban would not last are coming true

Middle East Eye: Over a month ago, a senior Iranian diplomat issued a warning that the Taliban, which recently regained control of Afghanistan, is a strategic threat right on Iran’s borders.

His warnings, which would prove to be justified within a matter of weeks, were dismissed.

“If the Taliban rules over Afghanistan with such an ideology, it will surely be a strategic threat to Iran. It is simplistic, thinking that the Taliban takeover will not affect our country,” Rasoul Mousavi, the director of the West Asia department at the Iranian foreign ministry, said on 28 October.

'Iran is worried that if it does not tolerate the Taliban's undiplomatic behaviour, Afghanistan will fall into the hands of Iran's enemies'
- Former Iranian diplomat

Hardliners vehemently attacked the veteran diplomat, who held the same position under the administration of moderate former president Hassan Rouhani, and called on the conservative Foreign Minister, Hossein Amir-Abdollahian, to relieve him of his duties. Amir-Abdollahian, however, did not listen to them.

On 1 December, Afghan news agency Amaaj released a video of an exchange of fire between Taliban forces and Iranian border guards. Soon after, Iran’s official news agencies confirmed the clashes, saying that the incident had taken place in the Shaghalak area of Nimruz province, near Sistan and Baluchestan province.

Meanwhile, videos emerged showing that several border checkpoints had fallen under the control of Taliban forces, but news agencies affiliated with the Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC) denied the reports.

A few hours later, Saeed Khatibzadeh, the spokesman for the Iranian Foreign Ministry, described the incident as a “border disagreement between frontiersmen” that was “managed and terminated” through “coordination between border guards of both sides”.

However, some unconfirmed reports claimed that the clashes had left casualties.

Iran's border with Afghanistan has long defined the country's relations with its neighbour, with the border the scene of activity by migrants, drug traffickers and armed groups. More importantly, two important rivers flow into Iran from Afghanistan - the Helmand and the Harirud - both of which are of paramount value to Tehran.

Following the clashes, IRGC-backed Tasnim news agency said that a few years ago, Iran erected a security wall hundreds of metres away from the Afghan border. Tasnim claimed that on the day of the border incident, the Taliban mistakenly thought the border was infiltrated when Iranian farmers crossed to the other side of the wall to access their farms, which fall on Iranian territory, and this led to clashes.

Reformists versus hardliners
Iranian reformists, who have been critical of Tehran’s diplomatic engagement with the Taliban over the past few years, lamented the government's current handling of the Taliban, which, up until a few months ago, was seen as no different from Islamic State in the eyes of average Iranians.

Abdollah Ramezanzadeh, the former spokesperson of former reformist president Mohammad Khatami, rebuked the government for its unclear plan regarding the issue.

“[Taliban] has begun its evil work on the borders, make up for your mistake and make your foreign policy [clear],” he wrote in a tweet on 3 December.

Ramezanzadeh had previously warned that Saudi Arabia would turn Taliban-governed Afghanistan into a base against Iran, the way he claimed Tehran had used Yemen against Riyadh.

Similarly, Hossein Dehbashi, a history researcher, slammed the government over the incident at the border, writing on 2 December: “Aren’t you ashamed of yourself that the Taliban crossed the border?”

Reformist activist Meysam Sharafi also took a swipe at hardliners and the state, saying: “Their strategy is probably submitting the land and buying time,” however, the Taliban “is no stranger, as they are the spiritual brothers of [these gentlemen in Tehran].” 

The normalisation of clashes
Tasnim news agency called the incident “a border misunderstanding”. Fars News Agency, which is also close to the IRGC, claimed that the clash happened between Iranian border guards and armed criminal groups.

Meanwhile, the conservative newspaper Kayhan, whose editor-in-chief, Hossein Shariatmadari, is appointed by Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, wrote: “The border encroachment took place in an area where the official Taliban border guards have not yet been deployed, but where gangs of thugs and drug traffickers are active instead.”

In a direct attack on reformist media, Javan, a magazine run by the IRGC, argued that: “Some news agencies have magnified the allegations about a border clash between the Taliban and Iranian border guards while we encountered gangs and drug traffickers.”

Interestingly enough, some conservative users on Twitter did not believe the narrative offered by hardliners on what transpired at the border >>>